Episode cover
← Small Town Murder

#448 - The Merry Mutilator - Onaway, Michigan

December 10, 2023·1h 12m

This week, in Onaway, Michigan, after a woman heads home, after a fight withe her boyfriend, but stops at rural bar, inside of a cabin to do karaoke. She disappears from the bar, leaving a couple of suspects, but one ends up being the real focus, when he not only admits to committing some inhuman acts, involving guns, fire, and a chainsaw, he brags about it! He continues this disturbing descriptions, even while being sentenced! Along the way, we find out that town names can cause real beefs, that not all small town folks are friendly, and that you shouldn't brag about your murder, as a judge is sentencing you!! Hosted by James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman New episodes every Thursday!