Episode cover
← Small Town Murder

#138 - The Cookie Monster in Walnut, Mississippi

September 26, 2019·2h 40m

This week, in Walnut, Mississippi, where the town doesn't know where to turn when a ransom note is found, after a college student goes missing. Who could have taken her? An outsider? The town maniac? Police quickly call in the FBI in a desperate attempt to find the missing young woman, hopefully alive. The whole thing ends up in a legal fight that lasts years, and causes some strong feelings! Along the way, we find out that sometimes a tow only needs one festival, that your history often tells your future, and that crazy can certainly be measured in your cookie eating to murder ratio!! Hosted by James Pietragallo & Jimmie Whisman New episodes every Thursday!